A recent study found that emergency Medicaid for undocumented immigrants accounted for just 0.4% of total Medicaid spending in 2022, equivalent to approximately $9.63 per resident in the 38 states analyzed and Washington, D.C.
This was the figure obtained after analyzing the data from the financial management report for that year of the Medicaid Budget and Expenditure System, reported researchers from Emory University; the University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora; and the Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health.
Such study was published for him Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).
Of the 38 states (76%) and Washington, DC, that reported emergency Medicaid spending, no significant differences were observed in state characteristics.
Proponents of reducing Medicaid argue that these cuts will not affect citizens. However, researchers stress that undocumented immigrants do not receive comprehensive health care options, calling into question the logic behind such cuts.
Understanding Medicaid
Emergency Medicaid is a restricted version of Medicaid that covers emergency medical care for those who meet all normal Medicaid criteria.
This emergency service primarily covers immediate and short-term medical treatment, including childbirth, and in some states dialysis and cancer treatments.
It is almost the only accessible avenue for health care these people have, as federal law prohibits undocumented immigrants from qualifying for comprehensive Medicaid, Medicare, and the Health Insurance Marketplace options under the Affordable Care Act (ACA).
Comprehensive or regular Medicaid is a broader program that covers a variety of comprehensive medical services for low-income people who qualify based on certain income requirements, legal status, and other conditions. It includes preventive care, prenatal care, medications, hospitalization, routine visits, and other necessary medical services.
Limitations and considerations of the study
Although the study provides useful data, it has significant limitations. 11 states did not report their emergency Medicaid spending, and the analysis does not include other public costs related to undocumented immigrants.
Medical care for immigrants at risk
The authors emphasize that reducing funding for emergency Medicaid could harm hospitals and doctors serving immigrant communities, negatively affecting health care in areas with large populations of undocumented immigrants.
What alternatives remain?
Undocumented immigrants who cannot access emergency Medicaid have some other health care alternatives in the United States:
- Community health clinics that offer low-cost or free medical services, often with care in Spanish and culturally adapted for immigrants.
- Medical discount plans or short-term private health insurancewhich although they do not cover emergencies or hospitalizations, offer lower costs for primary care, specialists and medications.
- Some states have subsidized state programs that provide access to certain medical services to undocumented immigrants.
- Nonprofit Organizations and Community Agencies that provide health care or referrals to accessible clinics and services for people without insurance or legal documents.
- Hospitals and emergency centers They must legally provide emergency medical care, but otherwise access is limited.
These options allow immigrants without legal immigration status to have access to preventive medicine and primary care, although with limitations regarding total coverage or hospital emergencies.
You may also be interested in: